Side-by-Side Comparison

Compare Insurance Companies

Unbiased comparisons of top insurance providers. Find the best coverage, rates, and service for your needs.

What We Compare

Price Competitiveness(High)

Customer Service(High)

Claims Process(High)

Coverage Options(Medium)

Digital Experience(Medium)

Discount Availability(Medium)

State Farm

Bundling & Service

4.5

Price: $$

Pros

+Excellent customer service
+Local agents nationwide
+Great bundling discounts

Cons

-Higher rates for some drivers
-Limited online tools

Get a Quote

Geico

Affordable Rates

4.3

Price: $

Pros

+Competitive pricing
+Easy online experience
+24/7 claims service

Cons

-Limited local agents
-Fewer coverage options

Get a Quote

Progressive

High-Risk Drivers

4.4

Price: $$

Pros

+Name Your Price tool
+Snapshot program
+Accepts most drivers

Cons

-Mixed customer service reviews
-Rates can increase

Get a Quote

Allstate

Claims Satisfaction

4.2

Price: $$$

Pros

+Claim satisfaction guarantee
+Strong financial ratings
+Safe driving bonus

Cons

-Higher premiums
-Mixed claim experiences

Get a Quote

How to Choose the Right Insurer

Step 1

Check Ratings

Look for A.M. Best A- or better, and high J.D. Power scores

Step 2

Compare Quotes

Get at least 3-5 quotes to find the best rate for your situation

Step 3

Read Reviews

Check recent customer reviews, especially about claims handling

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to Compare Real Quotes?

Get personalized quotes from the companies compared above and see actual rates for your situation.

Get Free Quotes